Points against and in favor of CAA and NRC

CAA and NRC, Should we protest against it or support it?

Since the time when Amit Shah entered the parliament with CAB it experienced a huge opposition from political leaders as well as people. But what I found is that in between this critical condition of our country neither government nor protesters had placed their points clearly. It seems that they had used a simple trick that “if you can’t convince, then confuse”. Media is acting like they had got a lottery. They had just used it as a way to get TRPs.

So in this article I had tried to put some points from both the sides. LET’S BEGIN.

If you don't know the criteria of pursuing Citizenship of our country then click this.

Now let’s see what are the points of government’s or people who support CAA and NRC:

1. Persecution of minorities in neighboring countries.

The worst part of partition was the religious interference. It was the partition over the religion. It turned into a huge persecution of minorities in both sides, but as India decided to became a secular country. So our gates were open for all religions. But Pakistan was not ready to show equality for Hindus in their land. So starting from that time till now many persecuted minorities from Pakistan entered India. Not just Pakistan but Afghanistan and Bangladesh is also known as Islamic countries.

So we are not asking people to come in India but creating a better place for those who had already entered this country after suffering from persecution. As refugees from these three countries had a different reasons from others thus they diverse a different law.


2. Creating a proper list of citizens:

There is lots of confusion related to the voting citizens of our country. So there is a huge requirement for a proper list of voting citizens.

3.  Enhancing government policies:

Proper list will help government to launch different scheme for different people according to their need and requirement.

4. Why not Rohingya, Chinese Muslims, Sri Lankan Tamil Hindus etc?

It’s true that our country also had refugees from different countries. But we need to understand that we have a law for they. But the condition for refugees from neighboring Islamic countries is different.  Even persecuted Muslims from any country could attain our citizenship according to our constitution.  

Points of protesters against CAA and NRC:

1. Economic problem for implementing CAA.

Steps like NRC had taken lots of money in Assam. It was calculated that it took Rs 399 per person in Assam. So its estimated cost for implementing in whole country is 54663 crores. And we all know our country’s present economic condition. So this action by government is looking a very dangerous step. Watch the following video just for understanding this point better.

2. Government’s Poor Competence:

We had experienced Demonetization, it was looking great when whole country was supporting government as they taught it will vanish black money from the country. But the result was annoying, according to RBI almost 99.3% currencies had came back to the government. This was disappointing for public. There are many examples which prove this trait of ruling party. For example, ban of illegal slaughtering house in UP. It was a great step but government had no plans for the bulls that after this decision were just became trouble for public. Many injuries and deaths had taken place due to these stray animals. And NRC in Assam (explained below) also looks like its example.

So how could public believe that this time it is going to be smooth, and almost a successful decision?

3. NRC in Assam:

 NRC was practiced in Assam, previous year by the government according to the orders of apex court. And the result was again disappointing. 19 lakhs people were out of the list including an ex-army personal, and family of a veteran. And according to survey majority of them were below poverty line. And if government is so sure about citizenship of Indians then why they failed in Assam. And According to Home Mister Amit Shah this time NRC will be practiced all around the country including Assam. Then it means all the struggle by people of Assam and money of government had wasted.

so that's it, I hope you had liked our work.

if you have anything to say regarding our blog or posts then please benefit us.

Subscribe our blog to get notification of our latest posts. share it with your friends.
Don't forget to follow us.

Thank you